Pocket Spring Mattress Vs Memory Foam – 2 Sensational Facts Revealed

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on whatsapp
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on whatsapp

Is it possible to test two completely different types of mattresses? A pocket spring mattress and a memory foam mattress are completely different types of mattresses as their primary materials are different. We took up the challenge and did the pocket spring mattress vs memory foam comparison test with firm determination. And what we found are really sensational!

QUICK COMPARISON

Preview
Take Care Pocket Spring 6-Inch King Size Spring Mattress(78x72x6 inch)
OUR PICK
Amazon Brand - Solimo Memory Foam Queen Size Mattress for Superior Back Care (78x60x8 inches)
Title
Take Care Pocket Spring 6-Inch King Size Spring Mattress(78x72x6 inch)
Amazon Brand - Solimo Memory Foam Queen Size Mattress for Superior Back Care (78x60x8 inches)
Primary Material
Pocket Spring
Memory Foam
Comfort
Medium-soft
Medium-firm
Sizes Available
36
9
Thickness
6", 8", 10"
5", 6", 8"
Warranty
10 Years
10 Years
Customer Rating
Prime Benefits
-
-
Price
₹ 24,955
₹ 24,499
More Information
Preview
Take Care Pocket Spring 6-Inch King Size Spring Mattress(78x72x6 inch)
Title
Take Care Pocket Spring 6-Inch King Size Spring Mattress(78x72x6 inch)
Primary Material
Pocket Spring
Comfort
Medium-soft
Sizes Available
36
Thickness
6", 8", 10"
Warranty
10 Years
Customer Rating
Prime Benefits
-
Price
₹ 24,955
More Information
OUR PICK
Preview
Amazon Brand - Solimo Memory Foam Queen Size Mattress for Superior Back Care (78x60x8 inches)
Title
Amazon Brand - Solimo Memory Foam Queen Size Mattress for Superior Back Care (78x60x8 inches)
Primary Material
Memory Foam
Comfort
Medium-firm
Sizes Available
9
Thickness
5", 6", 8"
Warranty
10 Years
Customer Rating
Prime Benefits
-
Price
₹ 24,499
More Information

Last update on 2019-10-15 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Pocket Spring Mattress Vs Memory Foam Test

Before comparing pocket spring vs bonnell spring, let us understand the difference between the two.

What is a bonnell spring mattress?

Bonnell spring mattresses are made of a traditional spring coil system.

A bonnell spring looks like hour glass. Bonnell springs in a bonnel spring mattress are interconnected by metal wire.

Pocket springs are individual springs wrapped in pockets of cotton or other materials.

The pockets are then stitched one to another.

They are not interconnected by any metal wires like a bonnell spring mattress.

The main advantage of pocket spring is that, the individual springs can move independently.

Bonnell springs cannot move independently as they are all tied together.

So, in a bonnell spring mattress, when pressure is applied to one side of the mattress, it is felt on all sides of the mattress.

When pressure is applied to any side of a pocket spring mattress, it is not felt in any other side of the mattress.

The Dreamlite mattress from Urban Ladder is made of bonnell spring. It is promoted as a cheap bonnell mattress by the company.

The Eurotop mattress from Springtek is made of pocket spring. It is promoted as a luxury mattress by the company.

We can understand the bonnell springs vs pocket springs better by comparing these two mattresses.

So let us compare these two mattress and find out more about bonnell spring and pocket spring mattresses and which one to buy.

Testing The Pocket Spring Mattress And The Memory Foam Mattress

After initial comparisons we will now look at the two mattress in more detail.

As always we tested the Take Care pocket spring mattress and the Solimo memory foam mattress on six parameters as below.

mattress selector

Test 1

Material

Take Care is based in Bhiwani, Haryana. The pocket springs in the Take Care Pocket Spring mattress are made of steel. There are two layers of foam – one on the top and the other at the bottom. The mattress is covered by a quilted fabric. All the materials in the mattress are of good quality.

4/5

Solimo is the in-house brand of Amazon. The Solimo memory foam mattress has 3 main layers. The top layer is the memory foam layer. The middle layer has a soft comfort foam. High Resilience foam forms the third layer. There are knitted fabric at the top and an anti-skid fabric at the bottom. All the materials in this mattress are excellent.

4/5

WinnerThe materials of both the mattresses are excellent.

Test 2

Comfort

The Take Care Pocket Spring mattress shows the true characteristic of a pocket spring mattress. The pressure on one side of the mattress is not felt on the other side. It is soft on the top. The springs are not felt by the body. 

3/5

The Solimo memory Foam mattress has a medium-firm comfort. It feels soft and responsive to body weight. At the same time the mattress also feels tough too.

4/5

Winner

Solimo memory foam mattress is more comfortable.

Test 3

Sizes

The Take Care Pocket Spring mattress is available in 36 readymade sizes. It also comes with a choice of 3 thickness levels – 6, 8 and 10 inches.

4.5/5

The Solimo Memory Foam mattress is available in only 9 readymade sizes. The mattress has 6 inch thickness.

3/5

Winner

Take Care pocket spring mattress has more readymade sizes available.

Test 4

Strength

The pocket spring coils are made of heavy-gauge steel. There is sufficient thickness in the foam layer on the top. The coils are not felt. The quilted fabric is stitched properly too. The Take Care Pocket Spring mattress is durable.

4.5/5

The firm layer at the base is made of high-resilience foam. Over this the there are two layers for comfort – a polyurethane foam layer and a memory foam layer. The mattress also has a knitted fabric on the top and an anti-skid fabric at the bottom. The stitching of the fabric and the bonding of the foam are all excellent.

4/5

Winner

Take Care pocket spring mattress has slightly better build quality. And being a spring mattress, it is definitely tougher than the Solimo memory foam mattress.

Test 5

Warranty

The Take Care pocket spring mattress has a 10 years warranty.

5/5

The Solimo memory foam mattress has 10 years warranty.

5/5

Winner

Both the mattresses have excellent warranty.

Test 6

Customer Support

Customer support is very good for the Take Care pocket spring mattress. Most of the customers are satisfied with shipping and returns.

4/5

The packaging of the Solimo memory foam mattress is satisfactory. Shipping is also satisfactory.

4/5

Winner

Both the mattresses are good with customer support and after-sales service.

Test Result

Take Care Pocket Spring Mattress
Average Score 87%
Solimo Memory Foam Mattress
Average Score 80%

The final winner in the pocket spring mattress vs memory foam test is the Take Care pocket spring mattress.

We will analyse more deeply below and find out a conclusion as to which one to buy.

But first let us look at the advantages and disadvantages of a pocket spring mattress and a memory foam mattress in related to the two products.

Pocket Spring Mattress Vs Memory Foam Comparison

Pocket Spring Mattress

Pros

  • Size
  • Strength
  • Warranty
  • Customer Support

Cons

  • Material
  • Comfort

Memory Foam Mattress

Pros

  • Material
  • Comfort
  • Strength
  • Customer Support

Cons

  • Sizes
  • Warranty

A Deep Look At The Results

We must not rely just on our foam vs spring mattress test alone to decide whether to buy a pocket spring mattress or a memory foam mattress.

The reason for this is a pocket spring and a memory foam are completely opposite materials.

A pocket spring is made of steel. So a pocket spring mattress has hardness of a metal.

Off course it also has foam on the top too. But we are just looking at the primary material here.

A memory foam is made from polyurethane foam. Hence a memory foam mattress is soft.

Apart from this basic difference – one being soft and the other being firm – there is a major difference between the two.

The major difference between a pocket spring mattress and a memory foam mattress is the responsiveness.

A pocket spring mattress cannot give proper support to the body. The major benefit of a pocket spring mattress is to not disturb the other partner.

A memory foam mattress can give a good support to the body. It responds to body weight. As the pressure points gets a good support, the spine is aligned straight. This reduces back pain.

So a pocket spring mattress is good for comfort while a memory foam mattress is good for avoiding back pain.

Now, in this comparison test we have found that the Solimo memory foam mattress has lost the fight against the Take Care pocket spring mattress.

Does that mean we should buy a pocket spring mattress?

Not really.

If we look closer we will see that the Solimo memory foam mattress has won the material and comfort rounds.

It has scored a tie in strength and customer support tests.

It has lost only in sizes and warranty rounds.

Material and comfort are very important while buying a mattress.

The only other thing which should be considered is the price.

We do not test any mattress with regard to prices because prices change all the time.

But as we write this review, the price of the Solimo memory foam mattress is lower than the Take Care pocket spring mattress.

And if we had considered the price of the two mattresses in our test, then the result could have been different.

Hence, keeping in mind the advantages of a memory foam mattress over a pocket spring mattress as above, we recommend to buy a memory foam mattress.

So here are the two sensational facts of this test –

  • Inspite of the pocket spring mattress winning this comparison test, we announce the memory foam mattress as the winner.
  • A memory foam mattress is capable of reducing back pain than a pocket spring mattress.

The Solimo memory foam is one of the best memory foam mattress as far as material, comfort and price is concerned.

You can click the button below and buy it.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Mattress Ebook

Get FREE Mattress Buying Guide

Thank You

Please confirm your email.

Click on the link in the email to confirm your subscription.