Cotton Mattress vs Coir Mattress: 3 Confessions

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on whatsapp
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on whatsapp

Cotton mattresses are cheap. On the other hand coir mattresses are costly compared to a cotton mattress. Both have been around for a long time. So why not do a cotton mattress vs coir mattress test and see which one is really the best?

The Cotton mattress vs Coir mattress Test

In this comparison between a cotton mattress and a coir mattress, we will test two actual products – the Sleepinns Amena cotton mattress and the Coirfit Beetle coir mattress. Comparing two actual products will help us to understand which of the two type of mattresses is better.

Feature Comparisons of cotton mattress and coir mattress

Cotton Mattress vs Coir Mattress: 3 Confessions

Sleepinns Amena

  • Filled with Indian cotton
  • Cotton cover
  • Two persons can sleep
  • Only one size
  • No warranty
cotton mattress vs coir mattress

Coirfit Beetle

  • Coir and polyurethane foam
  • Medium comfort
  • 4 inch thickness
  • Polycotton cover
  • 28 Sizes
  • 1 year warranty

Testing the Sleepinns Amena Cotton mattress and the Coirfit Beetle mattress

We will test the Sleepinns Amena cotton mattress and the Coirfit Beetle coir mattress on various important parameters. Analysing on these parameters will helps us to understand the various advantages and disadvantages between a cotton mattress and a coir mattress.

Material

Sleepinns Amena

Sleepinns Amena cotton mattress is made by Amena Enterprises. The entity is not very well known in the industry. The cotton mattress has pure cotton stuffed inside, which are of good quality.

4/5

Coirfit Beetle

Coirfit has 31 years of experience in the industry. They have 6 industry certifications to their credit. Coirfit Beetle mattress is made of coir as the middle layer and polyurethane foam as a comfort layer on the top. Both the coir and foam are of good quality.

4/5

WinnerThe score is a tie.

Comfort

Sleepinns Amena

The Sleepinns Amena cotton mattress is soft in comfort. The mattress is comfortable as per cotton mattress standards.

4/5

Coirfit Beetle

The mattress feels hard in comfort. Coir mattresses are generally medium in firmness. But we found it to be hard. So as per coir mattress standards, the comfort level of the Coirfit Beetle coir mattress is not upto the mark.

3/5

Winner

Sleepinns Amena cotton mattress is the winner in the comfort segment.

Sizes

Sleepinns Amena

Sleepinns Amena cotton mattress is available in only one size – 72X48X4. However we found it to be shorter than the specified size. So apart from non-availability of different sizes, the actual size is lesser than the specified size.

1/5

Coirfit Beetle

Coirfit Beetle is available in 28 different sizes.

4/5

Winner

The Coirfit Beetle coir mattress is the winner.

Strength

Sleepinns Amena

Cotton mattresses are generally not durable. They tend to get flat as the cotton gets depressed over time. A cotton mattress is also prone to dust and dust-mites. The Sleepinns Amena mattress do not have anything special to make it last long.

1/5

Coirfit Beetle

A coir mattress has a longer life span than a cotton mattress. The Coirfit Beetle coir mattress is strongly quilted and will not tear easily. However both foam and coir may sag after few months of use.

3/5

Winner

The Coirfit Beetle mattress is a winner as coir is generally stronger than cotton.

Warranty

Sleepinns Amena

The Sleepinns Amena cotton mattress do not have any warranty.

0/5

Coirfit Beetle

The Coirfit Beetle coir mattress have one year warranty.

1/5

Winner

The winner is Coirfit Beetle coir mattress.

Customer Support

Sleepinns Amena

There is no customer support for Sleepinns Amena coir mattress.

mattress selector
0/5

Coirfit Beetle

Customers of Coirfit can easily contact for customer support through phone and email.

4/5

Winner

The clear winner is Coirfit.

Test Result

Sleepinns Amena
Average Score 33%
Coirfit Beetle
Average Score 63%

Coirfit Beetle coir mattress beats the Sleepinns Amena cotton mattress by a huge margin.

Now let us take a look at the advantages and disadvantages of a cotton mattress and a coir mattress.

Pros and Cons of Cotton mattress and Coir mattress

Cotton Mattress vs Coir Mattress: 3 Confessions

Cotton Mattress

Advantages

  • Material
  • Comfort

Disadvantages

  • Sizes
  • Strength
  • Warranty
  • Customer Support
cotton mattress vs coir mattress

Coir Mattress

Advantages

  • Material
  • Sizes
  • Strength
  • Warranty
  • Customer Support

Disadvantages

  • Comfort

As we can see above from the coir mattress pros and cons, the only major coir mattress disadvantages is that it is not very comfortable.

If we do a comparison of spring mattress vs coir mattress, the major disadvantage of a coir mattress is the same – a coir mattress is not comfortable.

Other than this one disadvantage, coir mattress has many advantages as can be seen above.

Which mattress is good for health in India - Cotton mattress or a Coir mattress?

As far as health is concerned none of the two mattresses – neither a cotton mattress nor a coir mattress is good for health.

A medium-firm mattress is considered to be good for our health. That is they are good for avoiding back pain.

A cotton mattress has many disadvantages, as we have seen above. But people may prefer it for temporary purposes and especially because they are very cheap. Our advice is not to go for a cotton mattress at all – either for a short-term or a long term.

A coir mattress, on the other hand, is a better solution for short to medium term. There are many coir mattress brands in the market too. A coir mattress definitely has a long life-span, is easy to maintain and do not pose any health hazard. They have many more features than a cotton mattress.

There are many good coir mattress in the market. You can also buy the Coirfit Beetle coir mattress as it is very cheap.

So click the button below, if you want to buy the Coirfit Beetle coir mattress.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Mattress Ebook

Get FREE Mattress Buying Guide

Thank You

Please confirm your email.

Click on the link in the email to confirm your subscription.